Be Reasonable: Episode #062 – Kate Birch


This episode, Marsh is joined by homeopath Kate Birch. As part of the episode, Kate asked Marsh to watch two experimental homeopathically-encoded videos. If listeners would like to try the experiment for themselves they can follow Kate’s instructions.

Watch video 1 – 1M dilution: youtube.com/watch?v=winP706eFek

Then wait for one week, noting down what you are feeling and thinking about for that week.

After one week then watch the second video: youtube.com/watch?v=T7FjJCmufhQ

Play
  1. #1 by Jwa on June 24, 2019 - 16:05

    It sounded really hard to pin her down on anything.

    Things work sometimes, because I know they do, and when they don’t I just need to try harder. Basically it’s all feelings and you can’t use systematic data to show anything.

  2. #2 by Ron sorrell on June 24, 2019 - 23:59

    Is there a homeopathic remedy caused by my excessive eye rolling?

  3. #3 by Lee S on June 25, 2019 - 18:06

    F**king hell!!!
    Fair play to getting a bit harder than usual on her Marsh..
    ( Long time fan, first time commenter!)
    This woman is dangerous and deluded…. Advocating homeopathy for Aids????, And has absolutely zero understanding of the scientific method???
    On the bright side, this is an episode I will share amongst friends and family who think ” there might be something in it”
    Great work dude… And thanks for giving me a resource that proves even “experts” in homeopathy have no clue…
    ( The pregnant pauses in Kate’s answers speak volumes!)

  4. #4 by stefafra on July 30, 2019 - 17:33

    Is it only me findig funny to see a bunch of people grinding white powder in mortars and pestles after a clip from “trainspotting”…?

  5. #5 by SteveE on August 6, 2019 - 16:15

    She mentioned previously being taken to task over her claims by activists called quack[something] and I wanted to look it up. Did anyone catch the group’s name?

(will not be published)