Chris French: Lessons for psychology and parapsychology from the Bem controversy
In 2011, Professor Daryl Bem of Cornell University published a controversial paper in a prestigious mainstream psychology journal claiming to show that precognition (the alleged ability to sense future events psychically) was real. His results, based upon nine experiments involving over 1,000 participants, were reported far and wide by the science media. Many parapsychologists viewed this paper as long-awaited confirmation of the reality of psi but predictably sceptics criticized the studies on both methodological and statistical grounds.
To his credit, Bem stated that he wanted others to replicate his findings and even offered to make copies of the software he had used to run the experiments freely available to anyone who wanted to try. Richard Wiseman, Stuart Ritchie, and Chris French took him up on his kind offer and we each carried out an attempted replication of Bem’s Experiment 9, the one with the largest effect size. Unsurprisingly, none of the three studies replicated Bem’s results.
When we submitted our report to the same journal that had published Bem’s paper, it was rejected without even being sent out for peer review. Two other high impact science journals did the same thing, revealing a worrying bias in science publishing at that time. Eventually the paper was published in the open access journal PLOSOne (and has since been viewed well over 50,000 times). The controversy generated by Bem’s results and attempted replications fed into the so-called replication crisis in psychology which ultimately led to improvements within the discipline and beyond.
About Chris French
Chris French is Emeritus Professor and former Head of the Anomalistic Psychology Research Unit in the Psychology Department at Goldsmiths, University of London. He is a Fellow of the British Psychological Society and of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry and a Patron of Humanists UK. He has published well over 200 articles and chapters covering a wide range of topics. His main current area of research is the psychology of paranormal beliefs and anomalous experiences. He frequently appears on radio and television casting a sceptical eye over paranormal claims. His most recent book is The science of weird shit: Why our minds conjure the paranormal, published by MIT Press in 2024.
Safety & Comfort
We aim to be an inclusive organisation, welcoming attendees from all backgrounds, ethnicities, and genders. The directors reserve the right to remove any attendee whose continued presence represents a real or perceived threat to the smooth running of our events, or the security and comfort of other attendees. Anti-social behaviour will not be tolerated.